University, Lawyers, Business Groups Oppose Plan to Tighten H-1B Extension
Proposed USCIS rule could trigger thousands of additional evidence requests annually; supporters argue that independent reviews are necessary to prevent erroneous immigration approvals.

WASHINGTON: A proposal by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to change how U.S. immigration authorities review H-1B and other employment-based visa extensions has drawn opposition from universities, business organizations, immigration lawyers and employers, who warn that the measure could increase processing delays, costs and uncertainty for foreign workers and American businesses.
The University of Michigan, U.S. Chamber of Commerce, American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA), American Immigration Council and several other organizations have urged DHS to retain the existing policy requiring U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) to generally defer to its previous eligibility determinations when the same employer and worker seek an extension based on substantially unchanged facts.
The proposal, published in the Federal Register on October 14, would remove the deference requirement under 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5). It could affect several categories of temporary foreign workers, including H-1B professionals, L-1 intracompany transferees, O-1 workers with extraordinary ability and H-2A and H-2B seasonal workers.
The public comment period closed November 13. The proposal has not taken effect, and the existing deference regulation remains in place.
DHS estimates thousands of additional evidence requests
One of the strongest objections comes from the government's own assessment of the proposed change.
DHS estimates that eliminating deference would generate approximately 6,044 additional Requests for Evidence (RFEs) annually among roughly 208,000 petitions eligible for the existing policy.
An RFE is a formal request from USCIS requiring a petitioner to submit additional documentation before an immigration decision can be made.
DHS's analysis also found that the median time to an initial decision was 76 days for petitions involving an RFE, compared with 12 days for those without one — a difference of 64 days. That comparison does not necessarily mean every additional RFE would cause precisely 64 days of delay.
Opponents argue that the additional requests could force employers to repeatedly establish eligibility facts that USCIS has already examined.
AILA and the American Immigration Council, in joint comments submitted November 11, argued that DHS's historical analysis found no statistically significant corresponding change in denial rates when deference was previously withdrawn.
They contend that the proposal could therefore increase administrative work without demonstrating that it would produce better immigration decisions.
The organizations also questioned whether USCIS should devote additional resources to reconsidering unchanged cases while already managing substantial application backlogs.
University of Michigan warns of uncertainty for international employees
The University of Michigan has raised concerns about the consequences for universities and research institutions employing international faculty, scientists and other skilled professionals.
The university argues that the existing deference policy promotes consistency by requiring officers to recognize earlier eligibility determinations unless there is a legitimate reason to reconsider them.
Under the current regulation, USCIS may depart from a previous approval when it identifies a material error, a significant change in circumstances or new information adversely affecting eligibility.
The university's position reflects a broader concern among employers that an individual whose position and qualifications have not materially changed could nevertheless face a different eligibility determination when an extension is filed.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce has also opposed the proposal, arguing that predictable immigration adjudications are important for businesses making long-term investments in employees and operations.
Immigration researchers challenge DHS's denial-rate analysis
The National Foundation for American Policy (NFAP), a nonpartisan research organization, has challenged DHS's interpretation of historical H-1B adjudication data.
In comments submitted October 30, NFAP reported that the denial rate for H-1B petitions involving continuing employment increased from 5% in fiscal 2017 to 12% in fiscal 2018 and fiscal 2019, following USCIS's withdrawal of deference in October 2017.
NFAP also cited USCIS data showing that the share of completed H-1B petitions receiving RFEs increased from 21.4% in fiscal 2017 to 38% in fiscal 2018 and 40.2% in fiscal 2019.
The organization argued that DHS had not adequately reconciled those figures with its conclusion that removing deference did not produce a statistically significant change in denial rates.
The two analyses, however, examine different measures. DHS used a comparison-group methodology, while NFAP highlighted changes in overall H-1B adjudication outcomes across fiscal years.
Other immigration policies also changed during that period, making it difficult to determine how much of the increase was attributable specifically to the withdrawal of deference.
Small businesses and seasonal employers join opposition
The objections are not limited to technology companies and universities.
The National Council of Agricultural Employers (NCAE), which represents agricultural businesses across the United States, submitted comments on November 10 urging DHS to preserve deference, particularly for H-2A and H-2B employment extensions.
The organization warned that additional processing delays could have serious consequences for agricultural employers whose workforce requirements depend on planting and harvesting schedules.
The United States Immigrants Center, a California-based nonprofit assisting small seasonal employers, similarly argued that delays could be especially damaging to businesses operating with only a handful of employees.
In its submission, the organization said that employers with fixed seasonal start dates cannot simply postpone operations while awaiting immigration decisions. It asked DHS to withdraw the proposal or, alternatively, preserve deference for repeat filings involving substantially unchanged employment arrangements.
Immigration advisory practice America Visa Advisory and InHouse Core, LLC also opposed the measure, challenging the projected administrative costs and warning that employers could face additional legal expenses and documentation requirements.
The Center for Strategy and Applied Insights at immigration law firm Fragomen urged DHS to retain the existing policy, arguing that deference promotes consistent adjudications without relieving employers of their obligation to establish eligibility.
Supporters say every petition deserves independent review
Despite the opposition, the proposal has also attracted support from organizations and commenters who believe USCIS should conduct independent reviews of employment-based petitions.
America First Legal Foundation, in comments submitted November 13, argued that the existing deference requirement is inconsistent with the principle that petitioners must establish their eligibility for immigration benefits.
The organization maintained that an earlier approval should not create a presumption in favor of a subsequent petition, particularly if the initial decision was incorrect.
DHS has advanced a similar argument, saying that deference could discourage immigration officers from fully examining petitions and allow previous eligibility mistakes to influence later decisions.
The department maintains that removing the requirement would strengthen immigration-program integrity while leaving the substantive eligibility criteria unchanged.
Another commenter, American Tech Industry Worker, supported the proposal and called for more detailed documentation of the specialty-occupation duties performed by H-1B employees.
The submission argued that employers should demonstrate not only that a worker initially qualified for H-1B employment but also that the work performed and proposed for the extension continues to satisfy the program's requirements.
These arguments reflect a fundamental disagreement over whether prior USCIS approvals should receive special weight or whether each extension should be assessed without a presumption based on earlier decisions.
What the proposal means for Indian and Telugu professionals
The dispute has direct relevance for Indian professionals working in the United States, including Telugu-speaking employees in technology, engineering, healthcare, research and higher education.
For an H-1B employee seeking to continue working for the same employer in the same position, the existing deference policy provides a measure of predictability when the underlying eligibility facts have not materially changed.
If the proposed regulation is finalized, USCIS officers could reconsider those earlier determinations without being required to give them deference.
That could result in additional documentation requests and greater uncertainty for some employers and employees, although the precise effects would depend on how USCIS administers the revised policy.
The proposal would not automatically cancel existing H-1B approvals, eliminate the ability to request extensions or change the substantive qualifications for the covered visa classifications. It also concerns USCIS petition adjudications rather than the separate process of obtaining a visa stamp at a U.S. consulate.
For Indian professionals planning continued employment in America, particularly those navigating long-term immigration processes, the question is whether previously approved employment arrangements will remain reasonably predictable when an extension becomes necessary.



Comments