top of page

Indian Grandmother’s Case Inspires Bill to End Old Deportation Orders

2 days ago
4 min read

Proposed US legislation would allow certain deportation orders to expire after 10 years and offer eligible immigrants a pathway to permanent residency.


US Congress
US Congress

Washington: The deportation of a 73-year-old Indian grandmother who had lived in the United States for more than three decades has inspired a new immigration bill that could provide relief to thousands of long-term immigrants facing removal from the country.


Four Democratic lawmakers from California introduced the Protect Our Neighbors Act on Thursday, proposing that certain final deportation orders expire after 10 years, provided the individuals concerned have remained continuously in the United States and have no criminal convictions.


The legislation would also establish a pathway for eligible immigrants to apply for lawful permanent residency, commonly known as a green card.


The proposal comes amid intensified immigration enforcement under the Trump administration, which has placed long-term residents with outstanding deportation orders at renewed risk of detention and removal


A grandmother's deportation sparks legislative action


At the centre of the proposed legislation is Harjit Kaur, a 73-year-old Sikh grandmother who had lived in California since the early 1990s.


After her asylum application was denied in 2012, Kaur continued reporting to US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) every six months for more than 13 years.


Despite having no criminal record and regularly complying with immigration reporting requirements, she was detained during a routine check-in on September 8, 2025.


She was subsequently transferred between detention facilities and deported to India on September 19, without her family being given an opportunity to say goodbye.


According to her family and congressional representatives, Kaur had been attempting to obtain the necessary travel documents from Indian authorities and had not refused to leave the country.


Her family alleged that she was subjected to harsh detention conditions, including inadequate food, medication and sleeping arrangements.


Kaur's deportation separated her from children, grandchildren and a community in which she had spent much of her adult life.


What the proposed law would change


Under existing US immigration law, a final order of removal generally remains enforceable indefinitely, even when the government has not executed it for many years.


The Protect Our Neighbors Act seeks to change that position.


Under the proposal, a final removal order would expire after 10 years if the individual had remained continuously present in the United States and had not been convicted of a crime.


An immigration judge could renew an expired order only where the government established, through clear and convincing evidence, significant reasons for the delay unrelated to administrative or funding constraints, and demonstrated that renewal was in the public interest based on new evidence.


The bill would also amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to permit eligible individuals with expired removal orders to apply for permanent residency.


Applicants would be required to pay an application fee and undergo verification of their taxpaying status.


More than a million immigrants face removal orders


According to figures cited by the lawmakers from the American Immigration Council, approximately 1.19 million people living in the United States have outstanding removal orders.


A separate estimate presented to Congress by former acting ICE Director Todd Lyons placed the figure at approximately 1.6 million.


However, neither estimate establishes how many individuals would qualify under the proposed 10-year rule.


Many people with removal orders have remained in the country because of deferred enforcement, legal proceedings, stays of removal or other circumstances.


During these periods, some have established families, built businesses, paid taxes and become deeply integrated into their local communities.


What it means for Indian immigrants


The legislation could be particularly relevant to Indian nationals who have lived in the United States for extended periods while facing unresolved deportation orders.


However, the proposal should not be confused with a general immigration amnesty or a new green card programme for all long-term residents.


It would not automatically provide relief to H-1B visa holders, international students or employment-based green card applicants waiting in lengthy visa backlogs.


Its primary beneficiaries would be individuals who meet the proposed conditions concerning final removal orders, continuous residence and criminal convictions.


The distinction is important for Indian immigrant communities, where uncertainty surrounding visa status, employment-based immigration and permanent residency has become a major concern.


Lawmakers seek a more humane approach


The legislation was introduced by Representatives Lateefah Simon, John Garamendi, Zoe Lofgren and Juan Vargas, all Democrats representing California.


Simon said the proposal would give long-term residents an opportunity to move beyond old deportation orders and continue their lives in the communities they call home.


Lofgren, a senior member of the House Judiciary Committee and former immigration lawyer, argued that immigration policy should recognise individuals who have lived peacefully in America for many years.


Supporters contend that deporting people decades after their removal orders were issued can impose severe hardship on families and communities.


Critics of such proposals, however, argue that allowing removal orders to expire could weaken immigration enforcement and undermine the finality of deportation decisions.


A proposal, not yet a law


The Protect Our Neighbors Act remains proposed legislation and has not changed existing immigration rules.


It would need congressional approval and the President's signature before becoming law.


Until then, existing removal orders remain enforceable, and individuals facing deportation cannot claim protection under the proposed 10-year expiration provision.


Nevertheless, the legislation has brought renewed attention to a fundamental question confronting American immigration policy: *Should people who have spent decades building lives in the United States remain indefinitely vulnerable to deportation because of old removal orders?


For Harjit Kaur, the proposed reform comes too late to prevent her deportation. For other long-term immigrants facing similar circumstances, its passage could eventually offer a chance to resolve their immigration status.


Editorial note: This report concerns proposed US legislation and does not constitute immigration or legal advice.

Comments


bottom of page